A dark day for the UK – my early thoughts on the EU referendum

Yet again I find myself in a minority in a national vote. It was hard to take in the past – 1992, 2010, 2015 – but with those there was always the hope for the future. Now it is hard to see where. This is a backward step that cannot be reversed. This vote was always about more than EU membership. It was a vote about what kind of UK the people wanted. An open, inclusive, tolerant nation that saw itself as part of a wider world; or a closed one which saw divisions and barriers which it wanted hardened. 17.5 million people have voted for the latter. Some of those people may claim that they saw the vote as means of achieving the former, and I look forward to hearing from the left-exit voters and leaders how they will go about that. It seems clear, as it always appeared, that this has simply handed further power to the right.

For the past year I’ve had a divided life between home in Coventry – near University of Warwick – and a rented flat in London, in the borough of Lambeth, which is close to where my wife works. Coventry voted to leave; Lambeth had one of the strongest remain votes.  When the votes came in for Newcastle and Sunderland it was clear which way things were going. As someone who used to live in the northeast when I taught at Durham University it is devastating to see that the huge problems of that region are blamed on the EU and migration rather than domestic politics. Other places I’ve previously lived such as York and Bath voted to remain. The town I was born in, Ipswich, and the town where I grew up, Colchester, voted to leave. It is a divided country, by class, geography, age and other factors which may take some time to disentangle. 16 million people voted to remain. That at least gives some hope. But this was a one-off vote, the process begun cannot be reversed. Worse is to come. While the parties may have short term joy, the UK Independence Party and the bulk of the Conservative and Unionist party may have destroyed both the UK and the Union.

As an English European, an identity I saw as mutually reinforcing, rather than as an either/or, I feel that a part of that is being taken away. The EU was far from perfect, and there were serious problems with its democracy, its economic policies, its migration attitude and more. But it was a shared project to say that Europe in the second half of the twentieth century and beyond could be better, not just compared to the first half of the twentieth century but the centuries that came before. As a historian, a political theorist, a political geographer, those issues are very much in my mind. I have worked on two main topics in my research and teaching career – European thought and the question of territory. I will doubtless find ways to engage with the future politics and geography of the European continent, a continent of which the UK is and will remain a part, even though its future lies outside of the EU.

I worry for my non-British European PhD students, my European colleagues and friends who have made a life in the UK. I worry for my nieces and nephews, and the country they will grow up in. I worry for the future life of migrants, and the welcome they will, or will not, receive. I am married to a migrant, a US citizen who came here when we got married, took jobs in the UK, took citizenship and now works for the UK government on international development. What will be the future of that part of the UK’s role in the world? I worry for the future of the European project, which both includes and exceeds the EU. This is a dark day. Perhaps something good will come of this, but at the moment it is hard to see quite how.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Politics, Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to A dark day for the UK – my early thoughts on the EU referendum

  1. Arthur Alfreds says:

    As an academic, you are automatically part of an intellectual elite, and that is separate from the mass of people. many of whom can’t process these things at such a high level. You get a distorted picture of our species.

  2. stuartelden says:

    Thanks, but I’m not convinced by these comments (here and on Facebook). I began my piece by saying I was in a minority, but it’s not that small a minority – 16 million people share at least some of my views on this. I don’t think that it would be accurate to say that the ‘remain’ voters were more intelligent to ‘leave’ voters. I suspect voting analysis may say better-educated, but that is of course not the same thing. Academia has long since stopped being isolated from market forces and contemporary politics – if it ever was a detached ‘life of the mind’ it is no longer. What I thought was striking in this whole campaign was how little academics, derided as part of a wider group of ‘experts’,were listened to or even given a platform. In addition, and quite obviously, not academics think alike. I made reference in the piece to a range of places I’ve lived, and while many of these were locations chosen because of where I’ve worked, that’s not entirely the case. I was the first member of my family to go to university, and the only one who teaches in higher education. I completely agree that other voices need to be heard, and I do think that the left in Britain, and certainly Labour, has become disconnected from the working class. But that is a problem that goes far beyond academic perspectives.

  3. Pingback: A dark day for the UK – my early thoughts on the EU referendum — Progressive Geographies | multipliciudades

  4. It’s the fundamental economic and political/social issues that really matter, not the relative intelligence of the constituency that voted. Sometimes smart people vote for the wrong thing.

  5. Pingback: Most popular posts and pages in 2016 | Progressive Geographies

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s