Stuart Elden and Federico Testa, “A Footnote to Nietzsche: Carlo Ginzburg on Michel Foucault, and his 1964 review of Histoire de la folie”, Theory, Culture & Society, online first (open access)

Stuart Elden and Federico Testa, “A Footnote to Nietzsche: Carlo Ginzburg on Michel Foucault, and his 1964 review of Histoire de la folie”, Theory, Culture & Society, online first (open access).

Marking both the passing of Italian historian Carlo Ginzburg (1939–2026) and the centenary of Michel Foucault’s birth (1926–84), this article presents a translation of a largely unknown 1964 review by Carlo Ginzburg of Michel Foucault’s first major book, History of Madness. It was written when Ginzburg was in his mid-20s, before his first books, and originally published in the Italian journal Studi Medievali. The review articulates the young historian’s main criticisms of Foucault’s project, which will form the basis of his later assessment of Foucault. The translation is introduced by a detailed discussion of Ginzburg’s lifelong engagement with Foucault. It particularly focuses on his critique of History of Madness as about the act of exclusion rather than those excluded.

I came across a reference to Ginzburg’s early review of Foucault’s first major book when writing some short pieces about his work after his death earlier this year (see here and here). I’d not seen this review mentioned before, so tracked down a copy and asked Federico to translate it. We wrote the introduction together. My thanks to Federico for his translation work and the experience of working on the introduction together, and to Theory, Culture and Society for their interest in the idea, and for speeding it through the editorial and production process so it could appear in 2026 – the year of Ginzburg’s death and the centenary of Foucault’s birth.


Discover more from Progressive Geographies

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

This entry was posted in Carlo Ginzburg, Michel Foucault. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Stuart Elden and Federico Testa, “A Footnote to Nietzsche: Carlo Ginzburg on Michel Foucault, and his 1964 review of Histoire de la folie”, Theory, Culture & Society, online first (open access)

  1. adrianpaulmartin's avatar adrianpaulmartin says:

    ‘’’DOI not found‘’’ at the link you give, Stuart (at least for me here in Spain …)

Leave a Reply