Eduardo Gudynas has recently criticised David Harvey and his research team in Ecuador for ‘simpatico [sympathetic, nice or friendly] colonialism’ (Spanish/English).
The research team (Estefanía Martínez, Verónica Morales, Carla Simbaña, Japhy Wilson, Nora Fernández, Thomas Purcell and Jeremy Rayner) respond (Spanish/English);
An earlier English translation of the response can be found at My Desiring Machines.
Updated 16 October 2015 with links to translations.
Discover more from Progressive Geographies
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
We have now translated the original piece by Gudynas on the ENTITLE network’s blog: http://entitleblog.org/2015/10/15/friendly-colonialism-and-the-harvey-fashion/
Reblogged this on Progressive Geographies and commented:
I’ve updated this post with links to a translation of the Gudynas piece and the official translation of the response.
ridicoulous. Gudynas just itinerates the culturalist ‘critique’ against the ‘north’ by fetishizing otherness. And by the way: it’s not Harveys fault to be cited by the ‘wrong’ persons or for ‘wrong’ purposes (who judges this by the way?)
first critiques:
Pingback: Top posts on Progressive Geographies this week | Progressive Geographies
JM Alier – my own comment: “El año 2015 es pues el año del triunfo intelectual del post-extractivismo, y los aprendices de Harvey no se han enterado”.
See: http://www.rebelion.org/noticia.php?id=204595
Possibly true, but it is not one scholar against the other. And Harvey is now 79!
Pingback: Gudynas and Harvey et. al. debate on ‘friendly colonialism’ continues | Progressive Geographies